Butter is one of those ingredients that might not seem like much, but it can easily make or break a meal. For this reason, many people love making their own handmade butter. Handmade butter simply tastes better and makes you feel more connected with your food.
It can be difficult to know which butter maker to try, though. There are thousands of products on the market, making the process of selecting the right butter maker for you overwhelming, to say the least.
To make the process easier on you, we have analyzed 23 products and 859 customer reviews of the most popular butter making brands. After 32 hours of research, we have come up with our favorite butter makers in Canada in 2021.
To find out which butter maker you should select this year, read on. This roundup includes our favorite butter makers, including their strengths and weaknesses. At the end, we even provide a buying guide to make the narrowing down process even easier.
Let’s dive right in to these products to help you find the right butter maker for your home.
Following our last update, our favorite pick is the STX Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine. You want to invest in the best high performing machine? The LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine is a great choice too.
Butter Maker Comparative Table
TOP PICK – ELECTRIC
|STX Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine||
||9.2/10||See price on Amazon|
TOP PICK – MANUAL
|Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner||
||8.8/10||See price on Amazon|
HIGH PERFORMANCE PICK
||9.6/10||See price on Amazon
|Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker||
||8.6/10||See price on Amazon|
Our Top Pick for The Best Electric Butter Maker
The Best Overall Electric Model
If you are looking for the best overall electric butter maker, the STX Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine may be for you. We have named this our best overall electric model because it comes with all needed parts without breaking the bank. Although some users have trouble with their unit dying early, it seems that most people absolutely love this butter making machine.
Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine Video Review
What We Think of the Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine
The STX Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine is our favorite electric model because it comes with all needed parts, such as an official cookbook, silicone butter molds, kitchen mitt, spatulas, and more.
Given that this butter maker comes with all the needed parts, it means you can save money and time by not worrying about purchasing other needed equipment.
On the electric butter maker itself, there is an easy to use LED digital control panel and microprocessor. These features ensure that your butter creations are easy to make and precise. For beginners, this is a great feature because it makes butter making much easier.
This product is amazing. I have used it to make tons of stuff, like oil, butter, and tincture. All of my experiments turned out great and I loved all the accessories.
Something else we really like about this model is that it is economic and ecofriendly. With everything that comes in this pack, you could easily expect for it to cost over $200, but it is surprisingly affordable. Especially when you consider how much you can make in this butter maker, the price is very fair.
In the recipe book, for example, there are tons of recipes like Italian garlic herb butter. It also includes non butter related foods as well. Chocolate banana smoothies, low carb brownies, and gummy recipes can all be found in this cookbook.
The biggest downside of this model is that several people have had trouble with their models breaking prematurely. For example, some users experienced a broken device after just three uses. Some even experienced there model breaking upon the first use.
Overall, though, most users experienced a long lasting butter maker. For this reason, this is easily the top electric butter maker on the market. Whether you are looking to make special butter or something to spread the butter over, this butter maker has it all.
Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine Specifications
- Power: 110/120 V, 60 Hz
- Wattage: 800
- RPM: 15,000 mixer
- Overheating Protection: Yes, with auto shut off
- Batch Size: Mini or Full
- Includes: 1 main power unit, 2 filters, 3 spatulas, 1 oven mitt, 1 butter mold, 1 recipe, 1 instruction manual
- Weight: 4.27 kg
Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine Pros and Cons
- Comes with many accessories
- Suitable for many cooking recipes
- LED control panel and microprocessor
- Suitable for beginners or experts
- Some models break prematurely
Our Final Opinion About the Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine
(5.0 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
The STX Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine is the best overall electric butter maker. Because of its numerous accessories and cooking capabilities, you will definitely get your money’s worth with this product.
Our Top Pick for The Best Manual Butter Maker
The Best Overall Manual Model
Although the STX Infuzium 420 Infused Butter-Oil-Tincture Maker Machine is the best electric butter maker, you may want a manual option. Our favorite manual butter maker is the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Machine. This product is super easy to use and cute, though it may not be long lasting for people who use it frequently.
Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Video Review
What We Think of the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner
If you want to get some arm muscle while making butter, the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Machine is the best choice. This nifty contraption can help you turn whipping cream into homemade butter in about 10 minutes.
This manual butter churner is made from a glass jar. We love that this glass jar is dishwasher safe. It makes it very easy to clean, although you should not use abrasive sponges on it. We also love the look of this glass jar. It is really attractive and makes spotting the churned butter inside super easy.
My friend recommended this butter maker to me, so I tried it. I absolutely love it and it is so easy to make at-home butter with this device. I love it!
One issue that many people have with manual butter turners is that their hands and arms start hurting after awhile. Luckily, this model is designed to help combat this issue. The spinning handle and stationary handle are made from polished wood, which makes the experience more comfortable.
Though you certainly will get a bit of a workout with this machine, this manual contraption makes butter much quicker than others. You should only turn for about 10 minutes before your whipping cream turns to butter.
According to all the reviews we read, the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Machine is a great option for people who want to make butter occasionally. However, more expert butter users find this machine to not be sturdy enough for frequent use.
Nevertheless, we absolutely love the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Machine because it is affordable, easy to use, machine washable, and really attractive. All of these features make it much better than other manual butter makers on the market.
Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Specifications
- Capacity: 1 liter
- Dimensions: 11 x 27 x 16.5 cm
- Weight: 0.9 kg
- Color: Clear
- Butter Making Time: About 10 minutes
Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner Pros and Cons
- Easy to use
- Machine washable
- Not suitable for frequent use
Our Final Opinion About the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner
(4.2 / 5)
(4.0 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
If you are looking for a killer manual butter maker, look no further than the Kilner KLN21758 Butter Churner. This manual device will have you whipping up butter in no time and cleaning up the mess even faster.
Our High Performance Pick for a Butter Maker
The Advanced Choice
If you are a frequent butter maker, you may be looking for something a bit higher performance or upgraded. If that is the case for you, we recommend the LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine.
This butter maker is incredibly effective, complete with a downloadable app. Though it certainly costs more than other options on our list, it is the best choice for serious butter makers.
LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine Video Review
What We Think of the LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine
The LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine is the best butter maker on the market, though it may have too many contraptions and cost too much for infrequent users. If you are someone who takes butter making very seriously, however, you will not find a better model.
We have selected the LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine as our upgrade pick because it is a premium kitchen appliance. You can make butter, oil, glycerin, or honey all at home. You can even pair the device to your phone with the LEVO app for easy, wireless control.
This is an excellent product. I have made different types of oil and butter, and each one comes out with potent flavors. Cleanup is really easy. I recommend looking up different recipes on YouTube.
One reason we recommend this device to expert users specifically is that it can make an incredibly large batch of butter at once. It has doubled the capacity of herbal infusions, and it does not aerate the final product. This leads to a longer shelf life.
If you are making more butter, you want to know what cleaning is like too. All of the devices are dishwasher safe, making this butter maker one of the easiest to clean, despite all of its additional features.
The biggest drawback of this device is its price. If you are someone who does not make butter frequently, this probably will not be the device for you. We recommend going with something simpler. Another drawback is that it takes a bit longer to heat up than other machines, though many users did not find this that big of a deal.
With that being said, the LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine is our upgrade pick. Between its additional infusion size and app, the most experienced of butter makers will absolutely adore this product.
LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine Specifications
- Capacity: 19 fl. Oz.
- Dimensions: 17.53 x 20.07 x 32.02 cm
- Weight: 5.31 kg.
- Cycle Types: Dry, activate, infuse
LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine Pros and Cons
- App integration
- Larger size
- Machine washable
- Easy cleanup
- Takes awhile to heat up
Our Final Opinion About the LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine
(4.5 / 5)
(5.0 / 5)
(5.0 / 5)
(4.0 / 5)
The LEVO II Herbal Oil and Butter Infusion Machine is a serious contraption made for serious butter makers. Between its machine washable features and app integration, it can help you make a lot of butter at once with little to no extra work.
Our Budget Pick for a Butter Maker
The Most Affordable Choice
Just because you are on a budget does not mean you cannot afford making your own butter. With the Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker, you can be making butter in no time with minimal expenses too. Although it takes awhile to get your butter churned, it works, is easy to clean, and very affordable.
Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker Video Review
What We Think of the Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker
Butter makers on a budget will love the Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker. This butter maker is really easy to use and costs very little. Simply fill the container with heavy whipping cream and shake until butter is formed. The device even comes with a built in sieve that makes separating the buttermilk from the butter very easy.
Just as making the butter is easy, so is clean up. All parts of this device is top rack dishwasher safe. Simply toss all parts in the washer whenever you are ready to clean. This makes cleanup much easier than other handheld devices. The butter you made should last about one week.
This is my new favorite kitchen contraption. It was so easy to make the butter and it was a workout! I recommend making sure to shake up the cream when it is room temperature because it will make the butter much easier to shake and make.
There is one big drawback to this device. Most notably, since it is a shake method model, your arm will get tired really quickly. If you do not have a lot of arm muscles to begin with, it will take longer than the instructions recommend for making the butter, which makes your arms even more tired since you have to shake longer.
Despite this device’s downside, this is the most affordable option. Given that a sore arm is an issue for all shake butter makers, it is not something you can avoid with a butter maker of this type. For this reason, we recommend this as the top budget pick.
After all, it is really affordable, long lasting, and makes delicious butter. Not to mention, cleanup is super easy since the device is machine washable.
Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker Specifications
- Capacity: 1 cup
- Dimensions: 14.2 x 8.1 x 8.1 cm
- Weight: 0.39 lbs.
- Material: Plastic
Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker Pros and Cons
- Easy to use
- Machine washable
- Included sieve
- Shake design
- Get tired quickly
Our Final Opinion About the Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker
(4.3 / 5)
(4.0 / 5)
(4.0 / 5)
(5.0 / 5)
The Chef’n Buttercup Butter Maker is the best butter maker for those on a budget. Expect to have a good arm workout with this device. Still, it can make tasty butter in minutes without breaking your bank.
Alternative Products to Consider
ONGROK Butter Maker Review
The Best Alternative
If you want the best all around alternative butter maker, we recommend the ONGROK Butter Maker. This device is much like our favorite electric model in that it comes with all needed accessories and is suitable for a variety of recipes.
ONGROK Butter Maker Video Review
What We Think of the ONGROK Butter Maker
If you were not sold on our top picks, we recommend the ONGROK Butter Maker. This butter maker is suitable for a variety of recipes, such as butter, oil, desserts, and tincture. You can even use it as an oil infuser! To make using this device easy, it comes with a user guide and premium cookbook.
More so, the ONGROK Butter Maker comes with a number of accessories, like a cookbook, silicone gloves, filter bags, butter molds, and more. Much like our top electric model, this means you will not have to spend extra on additional parts.
Something else we love about this model is that it is incredibly safe. It has been laboratory tested and passed all needed tests. Plus, it comes with a risk free guarantee and is a 100% Canadian owned company.
I love this product. It is easy to use and clean. Everything works great and I love supporting a Canadian owned company. Highly recommend.
The biggest issue we have with the ONGROK Butter Maker is that it can break prematurely. Though the company responds quickly, no one wants to go through the hassle of getting a new model.
Still, this is a great butter maker to select if you want a versatile model. Whether you are infusing oil or making butter, the ONGROK Butter Maker has everything you need and more.
ONGROK Butter Maker Specifications
- Dimensions: 35.8 x 22.4 x 22.4 cm
- Weight: 3.4 g
- Includes: Extractor machine, gloves, filter bags, recipe book, instruction manual
ONGROK Butter Maker Pros and Cons
- Comes with all needed items
- 100% Canadian owned company
- Risk free guarantee
- Can break prematurely
Our Final Opinion About the ONGROK Butter Maker
(4.3 / 5)
(5.0 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
The ONGROK Butter Maker is a great alternative if you were not dazzled by our top four recommendations. No matter what you want to make, this butter maker can do it. Plus, it is incredibly safe and owned by a Canadian company.
Herbal Chef Butter Maker Review
The Easiest to Use
Some butter makers are confusing to use, but not the Herbal Chef Butter Maker. This butter maker takes the confusion out of infusion, though you might accidentally create so much butter that some of it goes to waste.
Herbal Chef Butter Maker Video Review
What We Think of the Herbal Chef Butter Maker
As we already mentioned, the Herbal Chef Butter Maker is incredibly easy to use, which is why we love it so much.
It only takes about 10 minutes to have a homemade batch of butter that you can use for cooking, baking, or spreading over toast. In addition to being easy to use, it is very easy to clean. It is made with stainless steel, making it super easy to wipe down any butter that is on the inside or the outside.
Something else we love about this product is that it is very economical. The price itself is very cheap. On top of that, it comes with a limited lifetime warranty. This warranty can assure you get your money’s worth.
I have never owned a butter maker before, but I love this one. It does the job great, and I would recommend this to a friend.
The butter maker also comes in three different sizes, including one stick, two stick, and four stick, allowing you to make however much butter you want. The issue with the four stick option is that you often create more butter than you can use, resulting in a lot of waste.
If you select the butter maker size correctly, you will not run into this problem. We definitely recommend this model because of its ease of use, cleaning abilities, and affordable price if you are new to butter making.
Herbal Chef Butter Maker Specifications
- Butter Production: 1, 2, or 4 stick
- Dimensions: 28 x 14.4 x 14.2 cm
- Weight: 970 g.
- Material: Stainless Steel
Herbal Chef Butter Maker Pros and Cons
- Easy to use
- Easy to clean
- Many size options
- Limited lifetime warranty
- 4 stick leads to a lot of wasted butter
Our Final Opinion About the Herbal Chef Butter Maker
(4.5 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.7 / 5)
If you want to make homemade butter but are worried about it being difficult, select the Herbal Chef Butter Maker. This butter maker is easy and easy to clean. Plus, it comes in many size options and comes with a limited lifetime warranty. Just make sure to select a maker that does not lead to a lot of wasted butter.
MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine Review
The Most Versatile Alternative
If you need a highly versatile butter maker, we recommend the MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine. This butter maker is suitable for just about any recipe you could want, though it is on the expensive side and the strainer is not necessarily the best quality. Still, you cannot beat the versatility of this model.
MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine Video Review
What We Think of the MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor
In terms of versatility, you are not going to find a better butter maker than the MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine. This contraption is suitable for many recipes and even comes with a 7 page recipe book. This recipe book tells you how to make lotions, smoothies, butter, candies, and much more.
In addition to the versatility, it is very easy to use. You just simply control the butter maker with the press of a button. It is microprocessor controlled, which guarantees precise and properly made foods and products.
I bought this for my husband because he loves competitive cooking contests and making his own sauces. I am so glad I bought this product. It is fantastic and the flavor comes out much better than it would on a stovetop. I recommend this to anyone who is interested.
It even comes with a fully automatic cleaning cycle, which includes one, two, four, and eight hour cleaning cycles. On top of all these features, it comes with a one year warranty as well, ensuring you get your money’s worth.
The major downside of this butter maker is that it is on the expensive side, and the filter does not work as good as it should. Given you pay so much for this butter maker, it makes sense you want one with all great features.
Nevertheless, the MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine is an all around phenomenal butter maker. It is incredibly easy to use, and you can use it for just about any recipe.
MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine Specifications
- Container Size: 40 oz.
- Voltage: 110 V
- Dimensions: 35.05 x 24.13 x 24.13 cm
- Weight: 4 kg.
MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine Pros and Cons
- Highly versatile
- Easy to clean
- Automatic cleaning
- One year warranty
- Filter does not work always
Our Final Opinion About the MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine
(4.5 / 5)
(4.9 / 5)
(4.5 / 5)
(4.0 / 5)
All around, the MAGICAL Butter MB2E Botanical Extractor Machine is the most versatile option on our list. Complete with a 7 page recipe book, you can use this butter maker for just about any recipe. At the same time, it packs of powerful punch that is impossible to miss.
Why Should You Trust Us?
All our recommendations on Achetezlemeilleur.ca are the result of many weeks or months of research, comparisons, analyses of user’s ratings and if need be, interviews with experts and scientists. You will quickly notice that the products we suggest here are not the most expensive or the most trendy: they are those that will best perform their daily tasks, passing all security, reliability and efficiency tests while having an appealing price-quality ratio for everyone.
In the end, the products we recommend are those we would have wanted to buy, or those we will choose for our friends and family.
Things to Know Before Buying a Butter Maker
Before buying a butter maker, you likely have a lot of questions you want answered. Below are some of the most frequently asked questions regarding butter makers.
Why should I make my own butter?
Making your own butter can be a super fun and enriching experience. It allows you to connect with your food in a way that simply buying the butter at the store can never provide. Make your own butter if you want to feel more integrated with the food you eat.
Additionally, making your own butter is a great choice if you want specially infused butter. There are tons of infusion options and recipes you may want to try. If you are a true foodie who likes special butter, getting a butter maker may be for you.
What are the downsides of a butter maker?
Although making your own butter is super rewarding, it comes with some downsides. Notably, it is much more expensive than simply buying the butter at the store. You have to buy the maker and all of the ingredients. After that, you might have to work really hard, depending on the model you get.
Depending on your palette or the people you are serving, your work and money may seem fruitless. Many people cannot tell the difference between homemade butter and store bought butter. This may make the money less worth it to those who cannot taste the difference.
Are butter makers suitable for beginners?
Yes. Almost all butter makers are very easy to use. Handmade models are incredibly easy for beginners since the design is basic and straightforward. Electric models are also easy to use, but you may need to read the instructions to learn more about your device specifically.
Why does my butter maker say cannabis infusion?
Today, many electric butter makers are made specifically for cannabis infusion. This is great for people who want to make edibles and other cannabis infused products.
If you do not want to make cannabis infused products, do not worry. You can easily use the butter maker without infusing cannabis into it. Simply do not use that feature if you do not want I, though it is there if you change your mind.
How to Properly Choose Your Butter Maker
Even when you know which butter makers are the best, it can be difficult to know which one you should select specifically. After all, not everyone makes butter for the same purposes. To help you choose between the butter makers we listed above, here are factors to think about first.
Electric vs. Hand Powered
The most basic question you should ask concerning your butter maker is whether you want an electric or hand powered option. This will largely affect the features and price of the model you select.
Traditionally, butter was made by hand. Today, there are tons of hand churning models that create butter either by shaking the contraption or turning it. This will make you feel much more involved in the process. Plus, these contraptions tend to be the most affordable.
The biggest downside about hand powered butter makers is that they are much more difficult to use. You have to rely on your own muscle to churn the butter, which can get tiresome after awhile. If you intend to make a lot of butter frequently, you probably do not want a hand maker.
In contrast, an electric butter maker turns the butter for you. What makes these devices so great is that they are easy to use, highly versatile, and do not make you feel tired after awhile. People who anticipate making a lot of butter frequently ought to go with an electric option.
Though electric butter makers have a lot of advantages, the biggest disadvantage is that they are expensive. Because they come with so many features, they tend to cost a lot more than the hand powered options.
Another factor you need to think about is how much butter you want to produce. If you do not need to make a lot of butter, small butter makers or hand powered options will be the best. In contrast, you should opt for a large butter maker or an electric option if you need to make large batches.
Many people who want a butter maker want a device that can make a lot of other items too. If you are one of these people, you need to look for a versatile butter maker. Versatile butter makers will be suitable for oils, butter, hand lotions, and more.
If you select a versatile model, expect it to cost quite a bit. Versatile butter makers often come with advanced interior mechanisms, which makes the cost go up. Additionally, they often come with additional accessories to ensure you have everything you need with the kit.
Not everyone will need a versatile butter maker, though. If you strictly want a butter maker that only makes butter, you can find really affordable options that are not versatile.
Something that similar to versatility but slightly different is additional features. Additional features can come with the butter maker, making it more convenient, easy to use, or anything else.
For example, many butter makers will come with additional accessories, such as a butter mold, spatulas, and oven mitts. These sorts of features will make the process much easier since you do not have to buy these items separately.
A more hi-tech feature to look for is app integration. Not all butter makers come with this. In fact, it is really rare to find a butter maker that comes with an app, but when you do find one, you might want to take a second look. App integration can make the butter making process so much easier.
Finally, the last factor to consider is price. Butter makers come in a very large price range. You should be able to find one that matches your budget, no matter how tight or bountiful it may be.
If you are on a really tight budget, you will want to look for hand powered models. Hand powered models have a much more basic design and include less features, making them way more affordable. If you still want an electric model, you can find affordable options, but you will need to look a bit more carefully.
In contrast, you may be looking for a super hi-tech butter maker. If that is the case for you, there are tons of upgraded or luxurious options to choose from. These sort of butter makers will come with a lot of features and digital aspects, making the butter making process much easier and convenient.
We do our best to provide you with a comparative guide of butter makers allowing you to choose the best product possible. If we are missing information or new models, do not hesitate to leave a comment below or to send us a message.